10 x Beep

[MatthiasS]

Did you try passive mode?

[MatthiasS]

Cycle 2 does not mean minutes, it means every second time = 30 minutes

[Warichet]

Did you try passive mode?

I've tried so many things...
I'll do it again

[Warichet]

Cycle 2 does not mean minutes, it means every second time = 30 minutes

OK
How long should I wait before seeing some result ?
The doc says: after re-boot, but .... how long ?

[Warichet]

Did you try passive mode?

Yes. No go.
To make sure, I force the KO FTP-Status to an irrelevant value (i.e. 9) after a while it is reset to 2. So 2 is the real status, and means "nicht speicher".
Doesn't help much.

Also, someone hinted for a hardware problem.
For me, it is hard to believe, nevertheless I swapped the memory bar.
Could it be the flash ? only for FTP ??? Mmmm
One fact still puzzles me: my problem appeared around the same time as I did the Pimp procedure. Maybe coïncidence.

Did I forget to check something ?
Troubleshooting procedure wrong ?
Any hint is welcome.

Those 10 beeps are driving me mad.

[MatthiasS]

I don't believe in hardware problems. Debug says "FTP error. Doesn't help much, but it is a clear hint.

Did you try a different path? Did you try "\" for example?

[Warichet]

Debug says "FTP error. Doesn't help much, but it is a clear hint.

Right !

Did you try a different path? Did you try "\" for example?

No, not yet, but I was thinking along those lines, especially a NAS access rights problem, or another subtle change introduced by a NAS firmware upgrade (it's not the first time they mess around).
So, I'm setting-up another ftp server.

Is there any way to force a save of the Remanentspeicher ? besides waiting 30 min ?

Thank you for your help, bringing hope back again.

[MatthiasS]

You can change to "everytime/jedesmal" = every 15 minutes

or

• Abhängig von der Einstellung des "Speicherzyklus" ca. alle 15 Minuten, wenn "Jedesmal" angehakt ist, oder des benutzerdefinerten Vielfachen (Eintrag im Feld "Benutzerdefiniert") von 15 Minuten, wenn "Jedesmal" NICHT angehakt ist.
• Je nach Einstellung der Ringspeicher erfolgen zusätzliche Sicherungen.
• Direkt VOR (before) dem Herunterfahren des HS/FS, wenn dieser über den Experten über den Punkt "Übertragen -> Nur Neustart" neu gestartet wird (only Restart).
• Direkt VOR dem Herunterfahren des HS/FS, wenn dieser neu programmiert wird
• Direkt NACH (after start with new project) dem Hochfahren des HS/FS, wenn dieser neu programmiert wurde. Es wird eine neue Projekt-ID verwendet.

[Warichet]

Did you try a different path?

I've setup another FTP server on a good old W2K.
Manually uploading files works fine.
Nothing comes from the HS.
This brings me back to the HS.

Let's forget about the Remanentspeicher for a while.
A simple FTP doesn't work either, might be easyer to debug.

Can someone provide me with the most simplistic setup for a FTP transfer ?
The one that couldn't fail ?

I'm beginning to suspect everything.

[MarkusS]

What about Wireshark on this W2K?

[Warichet]

What about Wireshark on this W2K?

ûûh !
Didn't think about it yet.
I am/was convinced about a configuration problem, bad syntax, bad FTP path, missing "/" etc... the classical errors from dummies ...
But you are right, I have to take it more seriously, which implies an adequate setup for sniffing.

[MarkusS]

Strange stuff.

For me, this works like a charm ...

FTP on Synology DS 1512+ / DSM 4.3-3776.

[Warichet]

For me, this works like a charm ...

OK
It must be me then ....
I've made a small setup with a hub inorder to sniff , the HS and a PC running Wireshark.
I filter on port 20 & 21
I see communication between the W2K FTP srv and the HS.
I see plenty of black lines "TCP DUP ACK" mmmm, looks no good.
I hope it's not a side effect of the test setup.

[Warichet]

For your information, a capture of WireShark
I'll try to do my best looking at it.

10.0.1.249 = HS
10.0.1.254 = W2K as FTP server
I wonder what those rdrmshc are

[HartmutB]

No real clue about your problem, but some additional hints:

- There's no need to setup "Netzwerk -> FTP" if you only want to backup your remanent memory. For this, simply use the settings at "Netzwerk -> Remanentspeicher" and activate only the first tab "FTP-Backup 1". You seem to have to setups to different paths /Ftp/HS/ and /HS/ (Tab "FTP-Backup 1" and "FTP-Backup 2"). This might confuse some things, too.

- Use passive FTP for "Netzwerk -> Remantspeicher", it's not activated on your screenshot (there is a similar setting, not only the setting at "Netzwerk -> FTP").

Regards,
Hartmut